For years, many educators checked Common Sense Education before bringing a new tool into the classroom. That source is no longer being updated. Common Sense Education paused its edtech reviews beginning in February 2026, and it now points educators to other resources, including the ISTE+ASCD EdTech Index.
The change leaves a gap for districts that relied on a single trusted rating. It also creates an opening. Rather than one organization issuing one score, the field is moving toward a model in which several independent organizations each validate a specific part of product quality. LXD Research is one of the organizations partnering with ISTE+ASCD in that effort, focused on third-party review of the research behind edtech products.
What changed when Common Sense paused its edtech reviews?
Common Sense Education’s review pages now carry a notice that the content is no longer being updated. According to Tech & Learning, the pause began in February 2026, and Common Sense is directing educators to its privacy ratings and to the EdTech Index. Common Sense has not published a reason for the pause.
Those reviews focused largely on classroom fit and usability. They were not efficacy reviews of a product’s research base. That question, whether the research behind a product holds up, now sits with other organizations.
Responsible Tech in Education gives districts practical advice for the transition: cross-check any rating service against their own privacy and procurement checklist, and ask vendors for the evidence behind their safety and efficacy claims.
How does the EdTech Index replace a single rating?
The EdTech Index does not issue its own star rating. Instead, each product page shows validation badges from independent partner organizations, and each badge states what was validated and who validated it. The badges are grouped under five quality indicators.
| Quality Indicator | Example validators listed by the EdTech Index |
|---|---|
| Safe | Common Sense Media, 1EdTech, FPF Student Data Privacy Pledge, iKeepSafe |
| Evidence-Based | Digital Promise, Leanlab Education, Instructure, ISTE Seal |
| Inclusive | CAST, Digital Promise, ISTE Seal |
| Usable | Digital Promise, CAST, ISTE Seal |
| Interoperable | Project Unicorn, Ed-Fi, 1EdTech |
Source: EdTech Index, “Using the EdTech Index to Validate Product Quality.”
What a badge tells you: A badge signals what was reviewed and by whom. It does not say whether a tool fits a particular school.
From one score to many validations
A single rating is easy to use, but it compresses many different questions into one number. A star score can blend classroom fit, privacy, accessibility, and research quality, and a buyer usually cannot tell which of those was actually checked.
The EdTech Index model separates them. Each validator speaks to one part of product quality, and the badge names both the claim and the checker. That asks more of districts than a single score did, because they have to read what each badge covers. It also gives buyers a clearer view of which claims have been checked by someone other than the vendor, and by whom.
The shift: Evidence is no longer one line inside a larger rating. It is its own validation, and it needs its own independent reviewer.
Where does LXD Research fit?
LXD Research is one of many organizations partnering with ISTE+ASCD to provide third-party review of edtech product research. Our role is to examine the studies behind a product’s claims and report what the evidence supports. Our published studies show the kind of research we work with, and our guide to getting ESSA certified explains the evidence tiers that reviewers use.
What should providers and districts do now?
For providers, the shift raises the value of independent evidence. A district comparing two tools on the EdTech Index will see which one has had its research reviewed by an outside organization. Providers who have relied on a Common Sense review should take stock of what evidence they hold, which ESSA tier it supports, and whether an independent reviewer has checked it.
For districts, the advice from Responsible Tech in Education holds: ask vendors for the evidence behind their claims, and look at who reviewed it. We see this transition as a chance to make evidence easier to find and easier to trust.
Want to know where your product’s research stands? Contact LXD Research to talk through a review.
Sources
Responsible Tech in Education: Common Sense pause resource. Tech & Learning: Common Sense Education will pause edtech reviews beginning February 2026. EdTech Index: Using the EdTech Index to Validate Product Quality.
Not Sure What Level of Evidence Your Product Has?
Get a research-path recommendation for your product, timeline, and procurement goals.
Book a Free Conversation Explore Our ServicesOr email us at info@lxdresearch.com
