ESSA-Aligned Badges
ESSA defines four tiers of evidence. LXD Research reviews product research against all four, and our Level 3 and Level 4 reviews are built on Digital Promise requirements and EduEvidence criteria that educators already recognize. Each review shows what the research found, what questions remain, and what to strengthen next.
One review covers every tier your research qualifies for.
What an ESSA-Aligned Badge tells you
Many products have research that falls at ESSA Tier 3 (Promising) or Tier 4 (Demonstrates a Rationale), and educators need a clear way to read it. Our team reviews each product study against the ESSA tiers and writes up four things: the research questions, how they were investigated, the findings, and the questions our reviewers have about the study’s design and execution.
Where relevant, we also note what the study would need to reach the next level. Educators can then put the findings in context, and companies can use the notes to plan future studies.
The standards behind Levels 3 and 4
The WWC evidence standards were written before ESSA created its four tiers. They cover experimental and quasi-experimental designs, which line up with Tiers 1 and 2, and they have no equivalent of Tier 3 (correlational studies) or Tier 4 (a research-based rationale). Since ESSA took effect, too few studies have been reviewed at those two tiers for the Department of Education to set clear criteria for what they should look like.
Digital Promise and EduEvidence stepped in with published requirements for Tiers 3 and 4, and that is why we use them. Our Level 3 and Level 4 reviews are built on their criteria, so a badge from us lines up with what districts and marketplaces see elsewhere.
WWC’s reach is also limited in practice. WWC reviews only a small share of the studies available to it. For example, an analysis of 252 WWC literacy intervention reports found that 6% or fewer of the available studies were selected for review. WWC finds those studies through ERIC, and most product research is never posted there.
Digital Promise requirements
We follow the requirements Digital Promise uses for its ESSA Tier 3 and Tier 4 product certifications, including the research foundation, logic model, and study documentation.
EduEvidence criteria
We apply the EduEvidence criteria for Efficacy Bronze and for Effectiveness Bronze and Silver, which set out what evidence supports each level.
How the ESSA tiers line up
Tier 1 follows the experimental standards that WWC and Evidence for ESSA also use. Tier 2 follows state criteria first, then Evidence for ESSA standards. Tiers 3 and 4 follow ESSA’s own definitions, applied through the Digital Promise and EduEvidence criteria above.
| ESSA tier | ESSA definition | Also reviewed by | LXD Research badge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tier 1, Strong | Well-designed and well-implemented experimental study | WWC, Evidence for ESSA | Level 1 Requires standardized measures |
| Tier 2, Moderate | Well-designed and well-implemented quasi-experimental study | State criteria, then Evidence for ESSA | Level 2 May use publisher-created measures with an objective assessor and validity evidence |
| Tier 3, Promising | Well-designed and well-implemented correlational study with statistical controls for selection bias | Digital Promise, EduEvidence | Level 3 Includes studies without a comparison group, such as dosage and outcome studies |
| Tier 4, Demonstrates a Rationale | Rationale based on high-quality research, with ongoing efforts to examine effects | Digital Promise, EduEvidence | Level 4 Research foundation and logic model, with a plan to study effects |
What we share with other independent reviewers
LXD Research works alongside nonprofit and academic reviewers, and many of our practices are the same as theirs.
Published criteria
Shared with Digital Promise and EduEvidence
Our Level 3 and Level 4 reviews apply their published requirements, together with ESSA’s own tier definitions. A study without a comparison group, such as a dosage and outcome study, can earn Level 3 when it is well designed and shows meaningful student growth.
Attention to how outcomes are measured
Shared with all of these reviewers
Level 1 requires standardized measures. Level 2 can use publisher-created measures if they are scored by an objective assessor and have validity evidence.
Sample size and impact
Shared with Evidence for ESSA
We weigh how many students were studied and how large the effects were, not design alone. We accept small studies and can combine samples across studies for an overall product level. A randomized study with no meaningful differences in growth or in grade-level attainment may be rated Level 2 or 3 instead of Level 1.
Research in ERIC and beyond
Shared with WWC
We upload our own studies that meet WWC criteria to ERIC (see Dr. Schechter’s ERIC submissions). We also review studies that are not in ERIC, since most product research is never posted there.
Review on request
Shared with Digital Promise and EduEvidence
A company can ask for a review of its research without waiting to be selected. Levels 2 and 3 can draw on publicly available data.
Independent validation
Shared with Evidence for ESSA, EduEvidence and Digital Promise
The price of every study we produce includes submission to Evidence for ESSA or EduEvidence for independent review. LXD Research has helped more than 40 products earn Digital Promise certification.
Get a free review
LXD Research is now listed on the EdTech Index. We offer one free review for each product we have not reviewed before. Existing contracts stay in place.
- Submit the formComplete the short submission form for your product.
- Upload your papersAdd up to five papers to the Google Drive folder. Surveys, testimonials, interviews and focus group findings can go in separate documents. We review all of it together.
- Receive a memoIt lists the badges your evidence meets, along with small fixes that would close any gaps.
- Talk it throughMeet with us for 30 minutes to go over the memo.
If a study needs more work, you can book a one-hour working session for $300. Ask about a working session
Submit your researchWhat you receive
Badge files
A badge file with a transparent background for each level earned.
A signed certificate
A dated certificate with the product name and a summary of the research.
EdTech Index profile
Badge display on your EdTech Index profile, which is free to create. The Index shows your highest level.
A ring for multiple studies
When a product has more than one study behind its level, its badge carries a blue ring that reads “Multiple Studies.” The ring lets educators see at a glance that the level rests on more than a single study.
Our badges are also being shared with district marketplace platforms such as Lightspeed and ClassLink. Each district decides which badges it displays.
Evidence for the products schools use
Districts use far more products than any single review system has covered. ESSA-Aligned Badges give educators one consistent way to read the evidence behind the products they use, from a first rationale at Level 4 to a well-controlled study at Level 1.
If a company shares research without an ESSA level, point them to our free review.
